|
AECbytes Product Review (March
29, 2007)
AutoCAD 2008
Product Summary
AutoCAD
2008 is the latest release of the leading
CAD application that features several 2D drafting
and productivity improvements, most of which
were developed in response to customer wish
lists and feedback.
Pros: Full
repertoire of 2D drafting and 3D modeling and
visualization capabilities; new features such
as annotative scaling, multileaders, and other
text and dimension improvements make day-to-day
drafting tasks easier and more efficient; new
data extraction capability and bidirectional
links with Excel makes it easier to create and
maintain accurate tables; several formatting
improvements that can improve the appearance
of drawings with less effort; real world lighting
and procedural maps for materials allow the
production of superior quality renderings; excellent
documentation makes the new features easy to
learn.
Cons:
Pricey compared with other drafting and modeling
applications; implementation of some features
is complex and non intuitive.
Price: Suggested
retail price in the US is $3,995; upgrades from
AutoCAD 2007, 2006, and 2005 are priced at $595,
$1,195, and $1,795 respectively; price of AutoCAD
2008 LT is $899.
After devoting the whole of last year's AutoCAD
release to a much-needed overhaul of its 3D modeling
and visualization capabilities (see my review
of AutoCAD 2007), AutoCAD returns to its 2D
roots with a vengeance this year, with a whole
slew of 2D drafting and productivity improvements,
most of which were developed in response to customer
wish lists and feedback. There is no change of
file format in AutoCAD 2008, making it a non-disruptive
release that will be easy to upgrade to for users
who have been clamoring for these improvements.
Let's take a detailed look to explore what they
are and how they work.
Annotation Scaling and Multileader Objects
Formerly in AutoCAD, if the same annotation had
to be displayed or plotted at a consistent size
in differently scaled layout viewports, it had
to be tediously re-created multiple times in different
sizes and on separate layers. To overcome this
limitation and make the annotation process more
efficient, AutoCAD 2008 introduces the concept
of annotation scaling, where objects commonly
used to annotate drawings such as text, dimensions,
hatches, blocks, and so on have a new Annotative
property associated with them. You can turn on
this Annotative property for a single object or
by object style, and associate multiple scales
with it. You can then set the annotation scale
for the layout viewports to control the size of
the annotative objects relative to the model geometry
in the drawing. There is also an option to control
the visibility of annotative objects based on
whether their associated scales match with that
of the viewport. Thus, you can choose to turn
off the display of all those objects if the viewport
is set to a scale that is not supported by them.
The implementation of annotative scaling is not
very intuitive and does take some time to figure
out. It can be best explained with an example.
All the annotative text shown in Figure 1 has
the Annotative property associated with it. The
difference is that the multiline annotation shown
in Figure 1-a has two object scales defined for
it (1/4"=1' and 1/8"=1'), whereas the
rest of the text has only one object scale (1/4"=1'),
as shown in Figure 1-b. You can see from Figures
1-a and 1-b how the multiline annotation displays
differently in model space based on whether the
Annotation Scale is set to 1/4"=1' or to
1/8"=1'. The visibility option has been set
to show annotative objects for the current scale
only, which is why in Figure 1-a, set to 1/8"=1'
scale, the remaining annotations cannot be seen.
Moving on to look at a layout viewport, you can
see that the display for the 1/8"=1' viewport
scale also shows only the multiline annotation
(Figure 1-c), whereas the display for the same
viewport set to 1/4"=1' scale shows all the
annotation objects (Figure 1-d), as the same visibility
option was also applied to this layout. The key
aspect to note, however, is the size of the multiline
annotation, which is the same in both viewports,
despite the fact that they are set to different
scales. The height of the annotation in the layout
views comes from its Paper Space Height property
set as part of its style, which in this case was
0.0625. Thus, the same annotation will print at
a consistent size even if it is appearing in different
scales in different viewports, without requiring
the user to create multiple instances of the same
annotation for use in different sheets.
Figure 1.
Annotation Scaling in AutoCAD 2008. (a) and (b)
show the effect of annotative scaling in the model
space, while (c) and (d) show how it works in
a layout viewport.
Another key feature related to annotation scaling
is the ability to modify the individual scale
representations of an annotative object, so that
it is best positioned and configured for a specific
scale. This modification can be done using grips,
as shown in Figure 2, where the annotative object
at the 1/8"=1' is being repositioned. While
this editing is being done, the display of the
object at all the additional scales that have
been defined for it is also temporarily turned
on, so that you can see how the display at the
current scale relates to all the others. Thus,
in Figure 2, you can see the display of the object
at the 1/4"=1' scale as well. The example
shown is the same as the one used in Figure 1,
the only difference being that the background
color was changed to white in order to see the
displays more clearly. You can also set the width
and height of the text for each display scale
separately by using the Text Formatting rulers.

Figure 2.
Modifying the scale representation of the multiline
annotative object shown in Figure 1 at one of
its two annotative scales. The display of the
object in the other scale gets temporarily turned
on.
The annotation objects shown in Figures 1 and
2 belong to a new object type in AutoCAD 2008
called "multileader" that is designed
to make it easier to work with multiple leaders.
You can create multileader styles similar to those
for dimensions, tables, and text using the Multileader
Style Manager, where you can specify whether the
type should be Mtext or a block such as a detail
callout or another kind of tag, along with their
corresponding options. You can also specify the
settings for the leader format, arrowhead, break,
and so on, and whether the leader is annotative
is not. The multileaders shown in Figures 1, 2,
and 3 were created using an Mtext annotative multileader
style called "global," shown in the
Multileader toolbar in Figure 3. It also shows
the different tools for creating and manipulating
multileader objects. You can create a multileader
object head first, tail first, or content first.
Once you have created a multileader object, you
can create multiple leader lines associating the
same note with different parts of the drawing,
as shown in Figure 3. There is a tool for deleting
leader lines when necessary. For those who like
their notes to be nicely formatted, there is a
handy Align Multileaders tool, which makes it
easy to not just to align a set of selected multileaders
but also to space them out evenly and make their
leader lines parallel to each other. Figure 3-b
shows the result of applying the aligning and
spacing options of the Align Multileaders tool
to format the multileaders shown in Figure 3-a.
Rounding off the new Multileader toolset is another
useful tool that lets you group several multileader
objects that have block content and attach them
to a single leader line.

Figure 3.
The use of the Multileader toolset to first create
multileaders and to subsequently align and space
them out evenly.
Text and Dimension Improvements
Text formatting in AutoCAD 2008 has been enhanced
to make multicolumn text a lot easier to create
and modify. You can choose between static columns
of a specified number, where all the columns have
the same height (except for the last column, which
may be shorter based on the amount of text), or
dynamic columns, where you can change the number
of columns interactively based on the column width
you set. Dynamic columns can be set to Auto height,
where all the columns (except possibly the last
one) have the same height, or to Manual height,
where you can adjust the height of each column
separately with grips. This is useful when you
want, for example, to wrap the text around a drawing
in a certain way (see Figure 4). Regardless of
the type of column formatting, text automatically
flows between the columns as text gets added or
deletedthe column heights no longer have
to be manually and tediously adjusted as before.
You can also insert a column break, when required,
to force text to start flowing into the next column.
Additional settings such as the size of the gutterwhich
is the space between columnscan be specified
in the accompanying Column Settings dialog, where
you can also specify exact values for the other
column settings such as width and height.
Figure 4.
Using Dynamic Columns with the Manual height option
to create a multi-column text object that is of
varying height and wraps around the drawing.
Other text improvements include better control
over paragraph formatting with new tab styles,
paragraph alignment, and line spacing capabilities;
better import of text created in other applications
with the paragraph formatting retained; and a
new spell-check engine that lets you search the
entire drawing or only through specified areas
of the drawing's text, with the added ability
to zoom to and highlight misspelled words so that
they can be clearly seen.
On the dimensions front, AutoCAD 2008 includes
a new tool to evenly space out parallel dimensions
for a neater appearance, similar to the spacing
ability of multileaders shown earlier in Figure
3. The same tool can also be used to align dimension
lines with each other by entering a spacing value
of 0. You can add a jog line to a linear dimension
to represent a measurement whose actual value
is not the same length between the extension lines.
The exact position of the jog can be specified
using grips. Dimension or extension lines can
now be broken where they intersect geometric objects
or other dimensions. Other dimension-related enhancements
include the ability to control the location of
the text of angular dimensions outside the angle
being measured; if the text is specified outside
the angle, an extended dimension arc is created
to place the dimension text. Arc extension lines
are also available when specifying the text location
of radius, diameter, and jogged radial dimensions.
Enhanced Tables
Tables have been substantially overhauled in
AutoCAD 2008 with several additional formatting
options and more powerful data extraction and
external linking capabilities. Table styles have
been enhanced to include more options for borders
and margins within tables and table cells. You
can quickly create new table styles from existing
tables in a drawing. In addition to table styles,
you can define individual cell styles that can
be applied to specific cells of the table. Figure
5 shows an example of a table style applied to
a schedule, and the subsequent application of
a new cell style called Right-justified to the
last column onlyall the other data cells
in the table follow the left-justification option
set for the table data as a whole. New number
and currency formatting within rows, columns,
and individual cells is available.
Figure 5.
Defining table and cell styles and using them
to format a table as required.
A table with a large amount of data can now be
broken using grips into primary and secondary
table fragments, in which the data automatically
flows from one fragment to the next, similar to
the multi-column capability for text shown in
Figure 4. By setting the Positions option to Manual
for the table in the Properties palette, its individual
table fragments can be placed anywhere within
the drawing instead of being forced to stay together.
Another useful new feature is AutoFill grips,
which work similar to the Fill Series in Excel,
and allows you to drag and automatically populate
table cells with incremental data such as numbers,
letters, dates, and so on.
Importing Excel data into AutoCAD tables is now
no longer dependent upon the standard Microsoft
OLE (Object Linking and Embedding) capability
but is instead facilitated by a direct bidirectional
data link. The Insert Table dialog allows you
to create a new Excel data link, which can include
an entire spreadsheet or a specific range of cells,
and use that data to create a new table, as shown
in Figure 6. The linked Excel file behaves as
an external reference and can be managed through
the Xref dialog. If the file is changed, the user
is notified and given the option to update the
linked data in the table. You can also change
the data in the table in AutoCAD and upload those
changes to the Excel file. This allows all linked
information to easily be kept current and in synch,
without the hassle of updating the tables or external
spreadsheets independently. You can choose to
retain the Excel formatting of the table, or apply
any of the table styles created within AutoCAD
to it. Figure 6 shows the data-linked table set
to the same table style defined in Figure 5.
Figure 6.
Creating a table with a bidirectional data link
to an Excel spreadsheet, which is also shown.
Another way to create tables in AutoCAD 2008
is through the new Data Extraction capability.
A Data Extraction wizard allows you to extract
property data from objects in drawings (including
blocks and attributes) and drawing information,
when can then be linked to information in a Microsoft
Excel spreadsheet and output to a table or exported
to an external file. Figure 7 shows this process
being carried out for all the door objects in
a drawing, resulting in the eventual creation
of a table capturing the attributes of all the
three different door types.
Figure 7.
The process of data extraction from a drawing
to create a table showing the attribute information
associated with its plumbing fixtures. The first
three images shows the Data Extraction screens
while the last image shown the resulting table
placed in a drawing.
Other Notable Improvements
In AutoCAD 2008, objects can display differently
in individual viewports in the layouts while retaining
their original layer properties in model space.
This has been made possible by the addition of
four new options in the Layer Properties Manager
dialog associated with a viewport, allowing users
to specify color, line-weight, linetype, or plot
style as an override for that viewport. The list
of overrides for a particular viewport can be
seen through the Viewport Overrides filter in
the Layer Properties Manager dialog, which is
automatically created when property overrides
exist for the current viewport. Another layer-related
enhancement is the ability to isolate one or more
layers to make it easier to work on specific parts
of a complex drawing. The objects in the other
layers get dimmed but they can still be still
be used for visual reference as well as for snapping.
You can specify the level of dimming through a
control on the Dashboard, as shown in Figure 8.
Figure 8.
Isolating a layer to work with it more easily.
Despite the focus of this release being primarily
on drafting improvements, AutoCAD 2008 does include
some lighting and rendering enhancements for its
3D users, demonstrated in Figure 9. The lighting
capabilities have been improved to include a choice
of photometric light sources, which use real-world
values and allow for more realistically rendered
images. It is possible to import the lighting
data from IES files and apply it to any light
object that has been modeled. For more realistic
outdoor lighting, a new Sun and Sky background
is provided with settings for capturing the intensity
and color of sunlight and the atmosphere in a
scene. Material rendering has been improved with
the addition of new procedural maps, which are
generated by mathematical algorithms and allow
more realistic materials to be created as compared
to texture maps. You can also apply advanced lighting
overrides at the material level to adjust aspects
of the light emission, reflectance, and color
bleeding; this provides more rendering control
than relying strictly on the light sources illuminating
a scene.
Figure 9.
The photorealistic rendered image resulting from
the new photometric light sources and accurate
Sun settings in a 3D model.
Other enhancements include the ability to manipulate
the visibility of layers in DWF files that are
being used as underlays, import MicroStation DGN
files as well as use them as underlays, and export
AutoCAD files to the V8 DGN format. An Autodesk
Impression toolbar provides access to Impression
commands for those who have the application installed,
and facilitates a smoother workflow between the
two applications. The Layer States Manager dialog
features improvements for editing and viewing
layer states in attached Xrefs. A new Xref Clip
option allows the hidden area to be quickly inverted,
either inside or outside the clipping boundary.
A new InfoCenter option on the menu bar allows
you to enter keywords or a question for help,
display the Communication Center panel for product
updates and announcements, or display the Favorites
panel to access saved topics. The layout tabs
have been redesigned to work more intuitively,
similar to sheet tabs in Excel. Several enhancements
have been made for customizing the user interface,
including adding, repositioning, and removing
commands, creating new toolbars, and adding to
or modifying panels in the Dashboard. AutoCAD
2008 runs on Microsoft's new operating system,
Vista, and is also available in a native 64-bit
version, which will be useful for those working
with very large files.
A quick note about AutoCAD LT 2008it includes
most of the new features of AutoCAD 2008, except
for data extraction and the lighting and rendering
improvements.
Analysis and Conclusions
AutoCAD 2008 features a host of drafting productivity
improvements, all of which should be very useful
for the vast majority of its users who still rely
heavily on creating drawings for their professional
AEC work. Following on the heels of the last release
which dramatically overhauled the 3D capabilities
of the application, this release is a lot more
modest in scope and ambition, targeted towards
making day-to-day drafting tasks such as annotation,
dimensioning, and creating and managing tables
easier and more efficient. The focus is also on
avoiding the duplication of data and reduced updating
of data, with features such as annotative scaling
and data extraction. For those who formerly spent
a lot of time cleaning up their drawings to make
them look neater, features such as spacing and
aligning multileaders and dimensions will prove
to be a real time-saver. Users who have taken
advantage of AutoCAD's revamped 3D capabilities
introduced in the last version will be pleased
with the new lighting and rendering improvements,
which go a long way towards producing superior
quality renderings in a reasonable amount of time,
such as the one shown in Figure 9 which took only
about 5 minutes to generate.
One aspect of AutoCAD that I have repeatedly
complimented in past reviews is the excellent
quality of its documentation. There is a New Features
Workshop, which contains a series of animated
demos and feature overviews that are very useful
in getting acquainted with the new features of
the application. Also invaluable is a paper manual
included with the installation CD that provides
detailed tutorials on using the new features with
the help of sample AutoCAD files, which are included
with the program. The regular Help system accompanying
the application is comprehensive and includes
several video tutorials to illustrate specific
features. In addition, the new InfoCenter field
on the menu bar makes it easy to quickly find
the appropriate section in the Help window for
assistance with a specific feature. All in all,
it is very commendable to see this much effort
put into maintaining as well as enhancing the
quality of the documentation, particularly in
comparison with many other applications that fail
to provide adequate learning support for their
users.
Those in the AEC industry who have begun the
transition to BIM may find it difficult to get
excited about this release of AutoCAD, but considering
that the big transition point from CAD to BIM
is still estimated to be five to seven years away,
any improvements in AutoCAD that can save time
and reduce tedium for its users will be appreciated.
From that perspective, AutoCAD 2008 can certainly
be rated as a very useful release, and my guess
is that Autodesk will continue to engineer several
such incremental improvements in future releases.
Of course, there are much less expensive drafting
applications out there which can get the job done.
But given that the writing is on the wall for
CAD in general, AutoCAD users are likely to stick
with AutoCAD and benefit from its improvements
rather than bother switching to another application,
especially when they know that they will have
to eventually move to a BIM application anyway.
Thus, AutoCAD has several more releases in which
to perfect drafting to death, figuratively as
well as literally.
About the Author
Lachmi Khemlani is founder and editor of AECbytes. She has a Ph.D. in Architecture from UC Berkeley, specializing in intelligent building modeling, and consults and writes on AEC technology. She can be reached at lachmi@aecbytes.com.
Have comments or feedback on this article?
Visit its AECbytes
blog posting to share them with other readers
or see what others have to say.
|